Picture from Pompeii
Overall C

Archeology can only tell us so much about Pompeii, but Hollywood is free to invent any story it likes. In this movie, set in the ill-fated city around 79 A.D., a gladiator (Kit Harington) takes on the greatest opponent of his life -- the erupting Mount Vesuvius -- in order to save his true love (Emily Browning).

Violence D
Sexual Content B
Profanity B+
Substance Use B+

MPAA Rating: PG-13 for intense battle sequences, disaster-related action and brief sexual content.


This script goes up in smoke--even before the volcano erupts

What happens when you take a historical event, which ends with an entire population being killed by an exploding volcano, and make it into a 100-minute movie? Well, you have to do a fair amount of postulating to fill in the details no one recorded. And that’s what the makers of the movie Pompeii have done.

In 79 A.D., the coastal city in the Italian region has become a kind of holiday resort for the Roman conquerors who’ve invaded the country. Severus (Jared Harris) and his wife Aurelia (Carrie-Anne Moss) are Pompeians hosting Senator Corvus (Keifer Sutherland) and his contingency of soldiers. Severus hopes to find favor with the Roman military leader and in turn the new Emperor. He’s made detailed plans for a new coliseum, bathhouses and brothels to be built in his city for the visiting Romans.

But Corvus wants something more. He desirers Severus’s daughter Cassia (Emily Browning) for his wife. The young woman, however, has just returned from a year’s stay in Rome and she wishes to have nothing to do with the cruel and corrupted commander. Instead, she has her eye on Milo (Kit Harington), a Celtic slave who fights in the stadium with the other imprisoned gladiators.

To allow for story development the script begins several days before the actual eruption—long enough for us to know that Corvus has had a previous encounter with Cassia and that it is unlikely she will be able to refuse the merciless Roman who is used to getting whatever he wants. There’s also a flashback to Milo’s childhood when Roman soldiers slaughtered his entire village in front of his eyes and left the little boy for dead in a pile of bloody corpses. (The scenes of stabbings, neck slitting and unrestrained killings during the attack are graphic and gruesome.) Now as a man, the gladiator recognizes Senator Corvus, and his right-hand man Proculus (Sasha Roiz), as the leaders of the massacre. That awareness sets the stage for repeated attempts to get revenge when Milo escapes his chains and comes face to face with the barbaric Romans.

Disaster movies follow a pretty predictable plot line. And Pompeii is no different. Audiences are continually reminded about the impending explosion with frequent shots of the imposing volcano. Meanwhile the citizens go about their every day lives—hosting parties, doing business, dealing with unwanted sexual advances and engaging in political intrigue—unaware each rumbling tremor is slowly crumbling the undergirding of the city.

When the mountain finally blows her top, blobs of fiery lava rain down on the buildings, starting fires and leaving bodies charred and burning. People are crushed by falling stones and milling crowds. A gigantic tsunami capsizes boats and crashes through the ancient streets, drowning hundreds, while nearby a man races his chariot down a road conveniently clear of debris and throngs of people. In the midst of it all, several characters still stop to settle old grudges with swordfights.

Unbelievable? Yes. A little disappointing? Well, sure.

In the 1970s movies like Earthquake, The Towering Inferno and The Poseidon Adventure were a dime a dozen. But special effects and a cast of big stars are no longer enough to please moviegoers. Now they expect strong storylines to build empathy for the characters and enough attention to detail that implausibly empty streets in the middle of a disaster zone don’t become a distraction.

Related news about Pompeii

Is There an Upside to a Disaster Movie?

Is There an Upside to a Disaster Movie?

Having a personal preparedness plan can take some of the worry out of what might happen.

Lego Dominates at the Box Office—Again

Lego Dominates at the Box Office—Again

Warner Bros. announced a follow-up movie to release in May 2017